Langley woman who had more than 80 animals seized has lost court appeal

Sandra Simans has been ordered to pay the SPCA $81,000

A Langley woman who is embroiled in issues with the SPCA— which seized numerous animals from her property — has had another appeal in dismissed by the court.

On Sept. 5, in New Westminster Supreme Court, Justice A. Saunders dismissed Sandra Simans’ request to strike down an order for her to pay $81,000 to the SPCA for costs the organization incurred in caring for the animals seized from her Langley property in 2016.

Simans, of 1atatime Rescue Society, petitioned the Supreme Court of B.C., seeking an order to strike down the Dec. 2, 2016 decision by the B.C. Farm Industry Review Board that Simans pay the SPCA $81,235.50 as the reasonable care costs it had incurred with respect to certain animals seized from Simans’ Langley property on Sept. 19, 2016, said the judgment.


The decision followed the Oct. 7, 2016 internal review decision by the SPCA’s Chief Prevention and Enforcement Officer that it was not in the animals’ best interest to be returned to Simans.

Simans operated an animal rescue operation through which she rescued animals and either placed them in adoptive homes or attempted to provide care for them herself. Simans primarily worked alone.

“The petitioners and the Society have a contentious history, dating back at least as far as 2009, which centres on the Society’s attempts to address the petitioners’ perceived failure to provide adequate space, exercise, clean environment, and veterinary services for the animals in their care,” cites Justice Saunders in the judgment.

The Society emphasized the need for the petitioners to reduce the number of animals in their care so they could adequately provide for them and keep them from falling into a state of distress. On June 13, 2012, the Society seized 68 animals — suffering from various physical ailments — from the petitioners’ care. Those animals were eventually returned to Simans.

On Aug. 20, 2016, the Society received a call from an individual who expressed concern for the animals in Simans’ care. A constable attended for an inspection on Aug. 24, 2016. Ultimately, the SPCA obtained and executed a warrant on Sept. 19. A veterinarian, Dr. Walton, attended during the warrant execution and examined the animals.

Dr. Walton observed that many of the animals were emaciated, lacking in basic hygiene, infected with fleas and tapeworms, and suffering from dental, skin, and other apparent diseases. He also recorded overcrowding in all areas of the facility and an inconsistent supply of water. The society seized 88 animals including 45 dogs, 18 cats, five goats, five chickens, five pigeons, three ducks, three sheep, one quail, one red-eared slider turtle, and one pot-bellied pig. The Society left three birds, a cat, and a rabbit. Three of the animals seized by the society (two dogs and a cat) were deemed to be in critical distress and were euthanized.

The SPCA returned to Simans’ 216 Street rental property in March this year. They removed 17 animals, including a female Ridgeback and her 10 puppies. The mother dog was suffering from untreated mastitis. Also seized was a greyhound, four cats and a rabbit with a broken leg.

At that seizure, Simans told the media that she is being harassed by the SPCA and that her animals are well cared for.


Just Posted

‘An officer and a gentleman’: Const. John Davidson is laid to rest

Thousands attend memorial service for slain Abbotsford Police officer

Photos: Rivermen sink Clippers

Game went into double OT

Hands-on history during Douglas Day at historic Fort Langley

Satchel and foot stool owned by Sir James Douglas put on display

Douglas Day celebration honours Langley’s pioneers

Theme of 159th anniversary celebration was history of transportation in the region

VIDEO: Langley bottle drive helps families fighting cancer

Team Keian event honours memory of six-year-old

VIDEO: Rare comic showing Superman’s 1st appearance to be auctioned

The 1938 comic features Superman hoisting a car over his head

VIDEO: Coquihalla closed both directions near Merritt

Detours are available via Hwy. 8 and Hwy. 1

VIDEO: The Last Jedi is going to be the longest ‘Star Wars’ movie yet

Newest movie in the franchise will beat Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones

REPLAY: B.C. this week in video

In case you missed it, here’s a look at replay-worthy highlights from across the province this week.

PHOTOS: Procession and funeral for Const. John Davidson

Thousands attended celebration of life for Abbotsford police officer

B.C. Liberal leadership candidates debate different paths for party

Third debate held Sunday, Nov. 19 at Nanaimo’s Vancouver Island Conference Centre

Apology to Canadians persecuted for being gay coming Nov. 28: Trudeau

Thousands were fired from the military, RCMP and public service because of their sexual orientation

Heavy rains, winds hit B.C.’s south coast

Localized flooding, gusts up to 70 km/hr expected for the Lower Mainland and Vancouver Island

High winds cancel slew of BC Ferries sailings

Travel to and from Victoria and Vancouver as well as Northern Gulf Islands affected

Most Read