Letter: Khadr settlement was government’s best option, says Cloverdale-Langley City MP

In a letter to the editor, John Aldag, Liberal MP for Langley City-Cloverdale, lays out the reasons the government of Canada settled with Omar Khadr and why he believes it was the right thing to do. File photo

Editor: I am writing this in response to the letter to the editor, “Khadr didn’t deserve a penny,” published in the Times on July 19.

It was an interesting piece that criticized the government of Canada for settling with Omar Khadr. This has been a very polarizing issue amongst Canadians, and many have expressed opposition to what they view as somehow rewarding an individual implicated in terrorist actions.

The reality however, like most situations, is not quite so simple.

Omar Khadr was suing the Canadian Government for having contravened his constitutionally protected rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Supreme Court of Canada had earlier found that the previous government had violated Mr. Khadr’s constitutional rights, and he was seeking $20 million in damages.

Mr. Khadr is a controversial figure in Canada, and I understand why people have voiced concern over his settlement with the Canadian government.

In the Langley Times letter, the author argued that even though the government would have lost the case, it still should have fought Mr. Khadr out of principle. This is a reasonable contention; however I believe there are two fundamental considerations which makes it the wrong course of action.

The first comes from a pragmatic perspective. The Canadian government would have undoubtedly lost the case. The Supreme Court of Canada had already rebuked the previous Conservative government three times for doing the same, and taxpayers had already spent $5 million fighting against Mr. Khadr. In addition to the $20 million in damages, taxpayers would have also been on the hook for incurred legal fees and expenses, only increasing the price tag of fighting a losing battle.

Ultimately, continuing the case was costing Canadians a great deal of money, and would have only gotten more expensive.

Second – and in my opinion the more powerful reason to settle the case – the Government of Canada under the previous administration had violated Mr. Khadr’s constitutional rights. Our Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects all Canadians, and we must uphold our country’s values even when it is difficult or uncomfortable to do so.

While being held in Guantanamo Bay, officials from the Department of Foreign Affairs Canada interrogated Mr. Khadr. They had full knowledge of the sleep deprivation and took advantage of illegally coercive measures he was subjected to. The Supreme Court of Canada ruled that while he was held in Guantanamo Bay, “the deprivation of [Mr. Khadr’s] right to liberty and security of the person [was] not in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice.”

More importantly, it stated that his treatment “offended the most basic Canadian standards about the treatment of detained youth suspects” and that the government of Canada was complicit in the violation of the Charter rights of a Canadian citizen.

Although it is controversial, our government had a pragmatic responsibility, and furthermore a moral obligation, to close the book on a long chapter of government failure.

I do not argue that Mr. Khadr has not engaged in troubling activity, only that his government had a duty to handle his incarceration in a legal manner.

By flouting our Constitution, the previous government set out on the road that has led to this decision. We believe that the rights of Canadians are unalienable, without exception.

John Aldag MP,

Cloverdale-Langley City

Just Posted

Promoting Langley City: new agency launches

Discover Langley City created in wake of split with Township

‘Hearties’ descend on Langley

Fans of TV show ‘When Calls the Heart’ have gathered in Langley for the Hearties Family Reunion

Surrey School District refuses to rent Bell Centre for Parents United Canada rally

Group is seeking court injunction to stop an LGBTQ program in public schools

Former U.S. Olympian urges audience at TWU to stay true to themselves

‘I made the decision to lie,’ says Marion Jones

Motocross kid takes torch from dad

The name ‘Charlton’ is synonymous with dirt bike racing

VIDEO: Sears liquidation sales continue across B.C.

Sales are expected to continue into the New Year

New B.C. acute care centre opens for young patients, expectant mothers

Facility aims to make B.C. Children’s Hospital visits more comfortable

Search ramps up for B.C. woman after dog, car found near Ashcroft

Jenny Lynn Larocque’s vehicle and dog were found in Venables Valley, but there is no sign of her

Holy Heritage Rail Batman: Superheros come to Cloverdale historic train

The Fraser Valley Heritage Rail is hosting its third annual Halloween rail adventure Oct 28, 29

Police officer hit by car, stabbed in Edmonton attack back on job

Const. Mike Chernyk, 48, returned to work Thursday

UBC medical students learn to care for Indigenous people

Students in health-related studies to take course, workshop to help better serve Aboriginal people

Dorsett has 2 goals, assist in Canucks’ 4-2 win over Sabres

‘It was a real good hockey game by our group,’ Canucks coach Travis Green said.

Berry disappointed: Bear tries to eat fake fruit on woman’s door wreath

A Winnipeg woman has taken her berry-embellished wreath down, after a hungry bear visited her porch

Man in custody linked police search near Salmon Arm

Police have not connected arrest to search at Salmon River Road property

Most Read