Letter: Who decides which animals have ‘souls’?

Editor: Re: ‘There is no humane way of taking a life,’ (the Times, May 24). The letter was in response to a previous Times article, describing how horse meat had been taken off the menu at a local restaurant.

I respect and accept Maha Kali for their decision to refrain from consuming meat in their diet — although such was not exactly made clear in their comments.

However, I do take exception to the precepts that animals have souls, that they mourn, love and think or that they fear and suffer.

Inarguably, these are all qualities we humans assign to ourselves. Yet, to suppose that such higher level functions exist across the scope of all life is a major leap.

Does this mean that spiders, flies, worms and grubs or lizards, snakes and beetle are likewise endowed with such feelings and concerns? If not, why not? Are they not also animals? Also, if not, who gets to decide which creatures have the capacity to love, mourn and experience fear, let alone possess a soul?

to take this point to an extreme, since plants are also ‘alive,’ shouldn’t we also refrain from consuming them? Perhaps their suffering is more severe than the creatures described by Maha Kali. Perhaps a plant’s screams, brought on by harvesting and consumption are outside our human ear’s ability to hear, listen and drive the needed change away from such horrid practice.

Sorry if I’ve offended anyone, but simply put, we each may choose many of the paths that make up a life.

If you choose to believe that all animals have a soul, then you must accept that others among us believe differently. More to the point, and is is important, these differences do not make those who believe them bad, wrong or mean. They are just capable of deciding for themselves what path is best for their life.

I’m glad Maha Kali loves animals — so do I — and I also enjoy meat in my diet, too.

Stephen Ross,


Just Posted

B.C. nurse offering helping hands to displaced in Bangladesh

Kalisse Barwich working with Samaritan’s Purse at a hospital that’s treating Rohingya refugees

Vancouver School District scoops up another Langley leader

Suzanne Hoffman has been hired as the Superintendent of Schools for Vancouver

Freezing rain expected on the Coquihalla

Wet weather expected to cause issues on B.C. highways

Lightning down Knights to capture Valley banner

Langley Christian heading into provincial championships as Fraser Valley champs

Court date for Cloverdale pastor, wife charged with multiple sexual assaults pushed until December

Samuel Emerson and his wife Madelaine Emerson were expected to enter a plea Tuesday

VIDEO: Rare comic showing Superman’s 1st appearance to be auctioned

The 1938 comic features Superman hoisting a car over his head

BC Hydro issues storm safety tips

Bulletin indicates “electrical contact incidents resulting in serious injury are on the rise.”

B.C. flaggers rally after colleague struck in Okanagan

Traffic Control Personnel respond to colleague being hit in Lavington

Washington Governor Jay Inslee visits B.C.

Premier John Horgan talks trains, pipelines with southern neighbour

Viral video shows deer killed on Snapchat in Campbell River

RCMP say they have identified those involved and are working with conservation officers

Man arrested Monday after Surrey Creep Catchers call police

No charges have been laid in second Creep Catchers incident in two weeks

BC Conservatives call for ICBC reform

Leader Scott Anderson of Vernon calls ICBC ‘national embarrassment

Cost to fix Phoenix pay system to surpass $540 million: auditor general

Michael Ferguson’s review hints the entire system should be scrapped

Most Read