Is iron sprinkling the best solution for our oceans?

Is sprinkling iron in the sea the best medicine for planetary health?

There is little doubt that our species has a huge impact on the planet.

Satellite images reveal a planet lit up by human lighting every night.

If we can transform the Earth at a global scale, might we be able to do some good through purposeful global tinkering?

Or does our hope lie in personal lifestyle changes, like driving more fuel efficient cars?

In 2007, Sir Richard Branson challenged the world to think big by offering a $25 million prize for the most innovative way to reduce greenhouse gases.

Planktos, a company headed by Russ George was hoping to win the prize. George’s solution was to fertilize the world’s oceans with iron. The idea was to feed iron-starved phytoplankton causing massive blooms to absorb atmospheric carbon and then sink harmlessly to the bottom of the sea.

When Branson’s prize was announced, Planktos invited Sir Richard aboard a vessel that would spread iron over 10,000 square kilometers of ocean off the Galapagos Islands so Branson could see firsthand how his own prize would help the planet.

Branson never got on that boat and neither did George. Amidst widespread criticism, the voyage was cancelled. Planktos ceased iron fertilization endeavours and George was fired. The proposed experiment helped spur the United Nations into imposing a moratorium on ocean fertilization.

This was not the end of the story. We pick up the story in the summer of 2012 off the British Columbia coast where a vessel was spreading 120 tonnes of iron off the islands of Haida Gwaii.

The captain of the mission was none other than Russ George.

The village of Old Massett that had put up $2.5 million to fund the effort quietly celebrated over the next few months. News of the operation did not hit the world stage until October when Ken Rea, Old Massett Chief Councillor, and John Disney, CEO of the Haida Salmon Restoration Corporation held a press conference at the Vancouver Aquarium.

Rea and Disney announced the apparent creation of a 35,000 square km plankton bloom that would help reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide and increase salmon populations.

The fertilization was done in international waters beyond Canadian jurisdiction and international measures such as the UN moratorium didn’t seem to mean much either.

But was it the right thing to do? Did it really work?

George skipped the press conference on the pretense that he was up to his ears analyzing the data to try to prove that sprinkling iron in the deep blue sea really did what it was supposed to do.

So is it a good idea to tinker at a global scale? Or should environmental prizes be reserved for communities that make lifestyle changes with global impacts like driving more fuel efficient vehicles?

David Clements  is a professor of biology and environmental studies at Trinity Western University.

Just Posted

Appeal filed in Langley condo case

Lawyer for buyers seeks a court order preventing cancellation of purchase contracts

‘Bad Ass’ Barry McQuarrie sentenced to 14 years

McQuarrie shot and killed his ex-girlfriend’s new boyfriend

UPDATED: Langley City bicycle patrols to address homeless problems

Council approves bike purchase for bylaw enforcement officers

VIDEO: Fatal crash in Langley

RCMP investigate fatal collision between a vehicle and a motorcycle in Aldergrove

‘I am still in awe’ says Aldergrove’s Martel

Ryan Martel enjoying rookie season with Calgary Roughnecks

Police release criminal profile of suspect in Burnaby teen’s murder

Marrisa Shen was found dead in a Burnaby park last summer

Small aircraft touches down on Calgary street

The twin-engine plane was apparently short on fuel forcing an emergency landing

Man charged in 1996 sex assault of New Westminster senior dies

James Gray was charged with a litany of assault-related offences against 79-year-old

5 to start your day

Police take down knife-wielding man, Port Mann Bridge closed Tuesday night and more

Issues split Trump and Macron, handshakes and kisses aside

Donald Trump and French President Emmanuel Macron professed a sunny, best-friends relationship

How hospitals prepare for mass-casualty incidents

Code Orange alerts explained following the Toronto van attack

Jury to deliberate after Cosby painted as predator

A jury of seven men and five women are to decide actor Bill Cosby’s fate

Memorial to victims of Toronto van attack continues to grow

The subway station where a van was used to run down pedestrians has reopened in Toronto

B.C.’s living wage increase curbed due to MSP cuts, child care subsidy: report

Living wage varies between $16.51 in north central B.C. to $20.91 in Metro Vancouver

Most Read