Township Councillors Kim Richter (left) and Angie Quaale (right). Supplied photos

Township council defeats conflict of interest motion

Kim Richter’s motion would have prohibited councillors from bidding on Township work

Members of council will not be barred from bidding on Township work.

Council defeated Kim Richter’s motion 6-3 on Nov. 6, which sought to pass formal legislation that would disallow sitting members of council to bid on Township work or to use their businesses to bid on Township work for the duration of their tenure on council.

Richter brought forward the motion after the Township hired Coun. Angie Quaale’s business to cater a farm tour in September. The Township’s legal team found no fault with the matter, however Richter believes it was a conflict of interest.

READ MORE: Richter advocates for new policy on hiring councillor’s business for Township events

READ MORE: Questions arise after councillor’s business hired for Township event

“In many respects, it’s disappointing that we have to put something like this in writing. But it is clearly an oversight in our policy manual,” Richter said.

“I think that we all have to have a common understanding of what is appropriate behaviour and what is not appropriate behaviour.”

However, Quaale called the motion is a form of bullying, and that the Community Charter, which governs all municipalities in B.C., already adequately covers conflict of interest issues. She said she is being targeted “overtly” and that she is “being bullied and threatened by another member of council.”

“I look at this job as community service. We’re talking about a lunch that was catered by my business for $1,200 — that’s what this has evolved from,” Quaale said.

“And truthfully, it’s exhausting to have to deal with this over and over again. This job will not continue to attract good people to want to sit in these chairs as long as people feel like they can’t run their own business and do something outside of their seat in local government.”

READ MORE: Township councillors speak out about bullying

Richter said the issue isn’t how much money the contract was worth, but the principle behind it.

“What happens if it’s, like, $15,000 next time, or $150,000, or $15 million? Like, what happens when we get a council of people who are only sitting on this council in order to further the ends of their businesses? Is that the right kind of council for a community?” she asked.

“We swear an oath of office … that says we are not going to take a direct or indirect pecuniary benefit. If our businesses are getting money from Township coffers, I think that’s a direct pecuniary benefit. And we need just to make sure that we’ve drawn the line, what happened happened, it’s over, it’s done, but let’s make sure now that it never happens again, and that’s the purpose of this motion.”

Coun. Blair Whitmarsh, too, noted that Section 107 of the Community Charter already covers the issue in detail.

“I don’t think that we, as the Township of Langley, need to develop our own standards that somehow we believe are higher or better than (what) the rest of the province falls under,” he said.

“The community charter is very clear and it allows people who live in a community to be able to function as a councillor and still operate their businesses.”

Mayor Jack Froese said it was “very disappointing” that the motion was on the table. He read Section 107 out loud to council to provide context.

“There’s many communities where members of the community do business with the municipality. I can’t say for sure if George Preston ever sold a vehicle to the Township of Langley, but if he did, he would have followed Section 107 of the Community Charter, or similar legislation that existed at the time. It’s something that happens, but there’s clear guidelines to make sure it’s transparent.”

Coun. David Davis, who voted in favour of the motion along with Richter and Coun. Petrina Arnason, said that the discussion was unnecessary as councillors should know not to mix their businesses with the municipality.

“I think that we, as elected council members … shouldn’t be going into business with the Township with a 10-foot pole,” he said.

“There’s another issue here … what about the other people who have put bids in to do business with the (Township)? All of a sudden, if they’re running up against David Davis, they’re going to say, ‘Oh, it’s a done deal.’ Common sense, and I know I’m going to get into heck for this, but common sense says we should stay right away from that.”

Quaale added that in the particular case of the catering contract, she was one of the few businesses that could meet the Township’s requirements to source the food locally.

“The reason that I bid on this process is because I’m really proud of what goes on here in Langley. I’m really proud of our farmers and the food producers that we have locally. And I have really good longstanding relationships with those providers,” she said.

“And the reason my bid was lower than every one else’s is because I wanted to do this to show the community, not for a profit centre.”

Furthermore, Quaale said that the conflict “is just one piece of what the community is seeing” and that this type of behaviour has been going on behind the scene since before she was elected.

“Truthfully, my point in all of this is who’s going to be attracted to sit in this seat when they see how we are treated by other members of council and by the public? The whole concept of public discourse has gotten so far off the rails.”

Richter countered by saying that council should watch the tapes of their meetings to “see who is harassing who.” She also said that the legal opinion on the catering matter offers “a very narrow description” and that there are two other sections of the Community Charter that were not referenced: Section 102 on restriction on inside influence and Section 103 on restrictions on outside influence.

“I think you have to draw the line in the sand early, it has to be firm and it has to be clear,” she said. “And to me, the line is, if you have put your name forward and been fortunate enough to be elected, then your obligation is to every member of this community, not just to your business.”

At the end of the meeting, Coun. Charlie Fox — who said residents have also questioned him about social media interactions related to the catering contract — put forward a notice of motion requesting a legal opinion as to whether the Township’s respectful workplace policy has been violated. If it has, he would also like to know what any options for recourse may be.

Just Posted

Township unveils new plans for museums, cultural centre, Aboriginal arts lodge

New homes and shops also included in Fort Langley proposals

‘There was nowhere to go’ — Langley couple caught in false Hawaii missile alert

Drew and Kailey St. Cyr were on their honeymoon in Hawaii when they received a terrifying message

Forgotten Set for Life ticket nets Langley woman $675 grand

Winning ticket, given to Janet Rube as a gift, discovered while she was looking for some paper work

Stealth work OT, come through with first win

Joel McCready nets winner, Eric Penney makes 52 saves as Vancouver knocks off Buffalo

Union files human rights complaint over Chilliwack school trustee’s LGBTQ comments

Board and trustee Barry Neufled facing $50,000 tribunal charge over alleged ‘unsafe work environment’

UPDATED: SUV fire at Langley mall (with video)

Firefighters respond to Fraser Highway incident

Kids chained in Calif. house of horrors; parents arrested

Authorities say an emaciated teenager led deputies to home where her 12 brothers and sisters were locked up in filthy conditions

‘Reprehensible’: Trudeau abortion policy raises ire of U.S. right

“This man is reprehensible,” tweeted former White House staffer Sebastian Gorka

‘I shouldn’t have to have a husband:’ Winnipeg woman criticizes men-only club

Jodi Moskal discovered the Winnipeg Squash Racquet Club continues to ban women as members, as it has done since opening in 1909.

Japan public TV sends mistaken North Korean missile alert

The false alarm came two days after Hawaii’s emergency management department sent a mistaken warning

Toronto girl dies after being pinned between vehicles while picked up from school

Police say an SUV with no driver in it rolled forward and pinned the girl against her father’s car

Freezing rain warning in effect for B.C. Southern Interior

Environment Canada issued the freezing rain warning for most of the Southern Interior Tuesday morning

Congestion points or distance: How Metro Vancouver could pay for its roads

Mobility pricing commission identifies two options in report

Pipeline routing through Chilliwack subject of NEB hearing Monday

City of Chilliwack, WaterWealth Project and local Sto:lo intervenors in the hearing

Most Read